Every year around this time, my phone starts ringing with the same conversation. A business owner opens a renewal letter in November, sees a rate increase well above last year's, and has six weeks to react.
Why Health Insurance Belongs in the Budget
Small employers compete for the same talent as large enterprises, but at a visible disadvantage. KFF's Employer Health Benefits Survey shows that 97% of firms with 200 or more workers offer health benefits, compared with just 59% of smaller firms (KFF, 2025).
That gap is an opportunity. Offering coverage helps your business stand out to job seekers right away. While monthly premiums are visible on an invoice, the return (avoiding costly turnover and long recruitment cycles) is real, even if it doesn't show up on a single line item.
The Hidden Costs of Dropping Coverage:
- 1. Turnover: Replacing a skilled employee often costs a significant portion of their annual salary, far outweighing an annual employer premium contribution.
- 2. Crossing 50 FTEs: Businesses with 50 or more full-time equivalent employees become Applicable Large Employers (ALEs) subject to ACA mandate penalties ($3,780 to $5,670 per employee) (Auerbach & Gussin, 2026). Note: Sister entities under common ownership aggregate toward this 50 FTE threshold.
- 3. Marketplace Shift: With enhanced premium tax credits expiring, asking employees to buy individual market coverage exposes them to significantly higher deductibles and premiums (ASTHO, 2026; KFF, 2026).
Step 1: Know What You Are Actually Budgeting For
Don't budget strictly off last month's invoice. A realistic health insurance budget includes:
- Total Premium: Employer and employee shares combined.
- Contribution Strategy: Setting a fixed dollar cap vs. a fixed percentage.
- Administrative Overhead: Onboarding, payroll deductions, and compliance.
- Assumed Rate Increase: Budgeting for an annual increase rather than hoping against one.
Real-World Case Study
Last year, I met with a South Florida business owner with a 20-employee group. She budgeted for a 10% increase, since most renewals tend to increase by 8%- 12%. Unfortunately, the group received a 15% increase. I searched for alternatives and presented a comparable medical plan closer to her budget, which she chose. The goal is to maintain good benefits within the company's budget.
As a rule of thumb, I tell my clients to expect at least a 10% increase at renewal, since rates rarely go down. If the renewal terms are fair, I often suggest clients keep their current plan. Employees already understand how the plan works, and you won’t have to worry about whether an employee’s doctor will be in the new network.
Whatever you decide, avoid going for the least expensive plan, as you will have no room in the future to lower the benefit option. Start with the best benefits plan within the company’s budget to leave room for adjustments if needed for future renewals.
Step 2: Pick the Funding Model That Fits Your Size
| Model | Best Fit | Budgeting Characteristic |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional Group Plan | Employers wanting predictable administration | Set at renewal; employer selects contribution share |
| Traditional Group Plan With a Designated HSA Plan | High-earners that prioritize tax breaks over possible out-of-pocket medical costs | Fixed monthly cost that must be paired with a high-deductible plan |
| Level-Funded Plan | Groups with healthy claims history | Fixed monthly cost with potential year-end surplus refund |
| Level Funded Plan With a Designated HSA Plan | Healthy work force that prefers tax breaks over possible out-of-pocket medical costs | Predictable monthly cost that must be paired with a high-deductible plan |
Pairing with an HSA? For 2027, IRS rules cap HSA contributions at $4,500 (self-only) and $9,000 (family) for qualifying High Deductible Health Plans (IRS, 2026).
If this is all starting to sound confusing, don't worry! I would be happy to walk you through your options. You can reach out via our website: Employee Benefits Solutions for Small & Mid-Size Businesses | MHG Insurance
Step 3: Build Your Timeline… Backward
- Request Renewals Early: Ask your carrier or broker for rate projections in writing as early as possible.
- Model 2 to 3 Scenarios: Compare other plan options before the final rate arrives. Work with your insurance broker to find coverage that is comparable to your renewal. Consider adjusting employer contribution levels to help manage costs if necessary.
- Adjust Plan Design First: Tweak deductibles, copays, or networks before cutting employer contributions. Employees feel payroll deduction changes immediately.
- Communicate Early: Announce benefits changes in late autumn to avoid end-of-year payroll surprises.
Let's Have the November Conversation Instead of the December Panic
Smooth renewals come down to starting early enough to evaluate your options. Renewals are generally available at least two months or earlier, and your insurance broker typically needs a week or two to review it. They should provide timely information and a thorough analysis of your renewal, with reasonable comparisons. In addition, your broker can suggest future plan enhancements you don't already have. Once the plan is confirmed, they should hold employee meetings to review any changes, assist during open enrollment, and be available throughout the policy year, whether to answer benefit or coverage questions or help with claims.
If you are reviewing an upcoming renewal or exploring group coverage for the first time, give me a call at 954-774-6975 or send me a message through our website. I’d be happy to help you find the right options for your team. You can also learn more on our MHG Small & Mid-Size Business Page.
References
Association of State and Territorial Health Officials. (2026). ACA enhanced premium tax credits: Legislative developments in 2025 and 2026. https://www.astho.org/communications/blog/2026/aca-enhanced-premium-tax-credits-legislative-developments-2025-2026/
Auerbach & Gussin. (2026). 2027 updates: ACA employer mandate. https://www.auerbachandgussin.com/blog/employers/2027-updates-aca-employer-mandate
Internal Revenue Service. (2013). Tax credit for employee health insurance expenses of small employers. Federal Register. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2013/08/26/2013-20769/tax-credit-for-employee-health-insurance-expenses-of-small-employers
Internal Revenue Service. (2025). Revenue Procedure 2025-32. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf
Internal Revenue Service. (2026). Revenue Procedure 2026-24. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-26-24.pdf
KFF. (2025). 2025 employer health benefits survey. https://www.kff.org/health-costs/2025-employer-health-benefits-survey/
KFF. (2025). When can small employers enroll in coverage through the SHOP marketplace? https://www.kff.org/faqs/faqs-health-insurance-marketplace-and-the-aca/when-can-small-employers-enroll-in-coverage-through-the-shop-marketplace
KFF. (2026). How much and why ACA marketplace premiums are going up in 2026. https://www.kff.org/health-costs/how-much-and-why-aca-marketplace-premiums-are-going-up-in-2026/
OnPay. (n.d.). The small business health care tax credit explained. https://onpay.com/insights/small-business-health-care-tax-credit/